GOAT Discussion

GOAT Discussion

Postby babylurch » 12 Sep 2016, 07:18

Last night's discussion in the box got me thinking a bit. I am not a big fan of GOAT discussions, for a number of reasons. Most notably, there is the difficulty of comparing people from different eras, with different roles on their respective teams (assuming team sports for the moment). There is also the fundamental question of what does the best mean. Is Peyton the best because of his tremendous regular season success, or is he disqualified because of his lack of success in the playoffs?

I guess that I am more interested in a dispassionate view of the usual suspects, without the overlay of trying to prove that they were the 'best'.

For example--Tiger Woods: remarkable dominance, and an amazing willingness to keep playing hard when it must have been tempting to mail in a performance in the Greater Louisville Open. Most impressive achievement to me was his cuts made streak. I never liked Tiger, so I would watch the cut line when he wasn't playing well on the chance that the streak would end. IIRC, he went birdie, birdie a couple of times to maintain the streak and even won a couple of events where he hit the cut on the number.
Downside: reputation for pushing the rules (getting the gallery to move a boulder, standing just outside of his playing partner's line of sight when they were putting. Deadly frontrunner, couldn't come from behind.

Is he better than Nicklaus? Who gives a fuck? They didn't play with the same equipment. In any event, I preferred to watch Miller and Mickelson.
2013 Jason McElwaine Regional Champion
User avatar
babylurch
Basketball Jesus
 
Posts: 4313
Joined: 11 May 2006, 16:07
Location: 2013 Jason McElwaine Regional Champion

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby Rodney Farva » 12 Sep 2016, 07:20

are we talking golf or all sports?
You coin contrarian bro and say shit nonsense like this.
User avatar
Rodney Farva
Your real father
 
Posts: 24492
Joined: 15 Mar 2005, 22:17

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby BostonSucksMyBalls » 12 Sep 2016, 11:42

I have done a definitive list of rankings of major sporting events, in terms of which are best thru worst. This is in sequential order. Sorry (not) for the lack of drama. I didnt include NASCAR, sorry mj.

1. NFL Playoffs
2. College Football Regular Season
3. NFL Draft
4. Royal Rumble
5. Golf US Open
7. College Football Final 4
8. NBA All Star Saturday Night
9. NBA Draft
10. Wrestlemania
11. The Open
12. NBA Playoffs
13. PGA Championship
14. NHL Playoffs
15. Womens Beach Volleyball
16. Boxing
17. Masters
18. Winter X Games
19. Summer X Games
20. Horse Race (one of the main 3)
21. MLB Playoffs
22. Soccer World Cup
23. Tennis Wimbledon
24. NFL Opening Thursday Night
25. Home Run Derby
26. NBA ASG
27. Tennis US Open
28. MLB ASG
29. UFC
30. Ryder Cup
31. MLB Opening Day
32. NHL Skills Competition (Is this a thing?)
33. NHL ASG
34. NFL Pro Bowl

EDIT bc I forgot March Madness. That can be #3. Everything else slide down one.
PS: I will never like July 27th. It will always be the day Reggie died. I just hate this day. True Celtic fans know what I mean.

"i'm relatively confident her asshole" - Farva
User avatar
BostonSucksMyBalls
Work Creep
 
Posts: 30190
Joined: 26 Aug 2005, 09:59

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby mj3528 » 12 Sep 2016, 11:47

Rodney Farva wrote:are we talking golf or all sports?


I think the golf GOAT discussion is easy.

At his height, Tiger was better than Nicklaus. Over the length of their respective careers Nicklaus is better than Tiger.
2009 NFL Pick 'em Champion
SOTSG Fantasy Basketball (Almost Entirely) 2012 Champion
2015 SOTSG NFL Survivor Champion, Part 2
2015 SOTSG Death Pool Co-Champion
2017 SOTSG Fantasy Basketball Champion
User avatar
mj3528
Never Forgotten
 
Posts: 8729
Joined: 05 Mar 2008, 18:41

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby Prez » 12 Sep 2016, 12:12

BostonSucksMyBalls wrote:I have done a definitive list of rankings of major sporting events, in terms of which are best thru worst. This is in sequential order. Sorry (not) for the lack of drama. I didnt include NASCAR, sorry mj.

4. Royal Rumble


This list in invalid.
Ballz: So, I fucking got a BJ for $250 total, and wore a rubber. It sucked, I couldnt even feel it, so i jeckyled onto her tits. She was cute. Not even that far out of my league, it was a waste of $250
User avatar
Prez
The MAWG
 
Posts: 9930
Joined: 17 Nov 2004, 08:53
Location: Ballz deep in golf groupie pussy

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby mj3528 » 12 Sep 2016, 12:13

Prez wrote:
BostonSucksMyBalls wrote:I have done a definitive list of rankings of major sporting events, in terms of which are best thru worst. This is in sequential order. Sorry (not) for the lack of drama. I didnt include NASCAR, sorry mj.

4. Royal Rumble


This list in invalid.


there is so much wrong with the list you can't even begin, even if you just eliminate any wrestling references.
2009 NFL Pick 'em Champion
SOTSG Fantasy Basketball (Almost Entirely) 2012 Champion
2015 SOTSG NFL Survivor Champion, Part 2
2015 SOTSG Death Pool Co-Champion
2017 SOTSG Fantasy Basketball Champion
User avatar
mj3528
Never Forgotten
 
Posts: 8729
Joined: 05 Mar 2008, 18:41

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby Gregs Kite » 12 Sep 2016, 12:14

I got to number two and laffed.
You fuckers ruined kite.

Apr 22, 2015 3:49 pm Clayton Bigsby i enjoy sports

BostonSucksMyBalls - Thu May 11, 2017 2:07 pm: greg your being a lil bitch in the hall of sand

Frank the Tank wrote:If I die I leave my red font to Kite.
User avatar
Gregs Kite
Friend of Friends
 
Posts: 22041
Joined: 20 Jan 2007, 15:59
Location: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re: GOAT Discussion

Postby babylurch » 12 Sep 2016, 13:19

mj3528 wrote:
Rodney Farva wrote:are we talking golf or all sports?


I think the golf GOAT discussion is easy.

At his height, Tiger was better than Nicklaus. Over the length of their respective careers Nicklaus is better than Tiger.

No longer pound for pound, now inch for inch?
2013 Jason McElwaine Regional Champion
User avatar
babylurch
Basketball Jesus
 
Posts: 4313
Joined: 11 May 2006, 16:07
Location: 2013 Jason McElwaine Regional Champion


Return to Other Sports

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest